• vonnik a day ago

    The crazy thing about semicolons is that they were once common in books intended for young adults/middle readers. See E. Nesbit and co. When I read the childrens' authors of early 20C Britain, I often think their writing is more demanding that books marketed to today's adults.

    • lapsis_beeftech a day ago

      The semicolon has always been the neglected underdog of punctuation; I try to sneak one in wherever I think I can get away with it.

      • Ozarkian a day ago

        I would like to disagree with you; however, your sentiment is based on sound grammar.

      • southernplaces7 17 hours ago

        Good riddance. I'll go with what Vonnegut said on them.

        “Here is a lesson in creative writing. First rule: Do not use semicolons. They are transvestite hermaphrodites representing absolutely nothing. All they do is show you've been to college.”

        • phoe-krk a day ago

          It's certainly a crisis in the Lisp world; everyone seems to be writing fewer comments.

          • lemonwaterlime a day ago

            Outside of coding, I seldom use semicolons; however, they do have their uses in certain cases—when there are two complete thoughts in the sentence.

            • derbOac a day ago

              The cited Guardian article is worth reading as well if you're interested; there's a usage quiz with it: https://www.theguardian.com/science/2025/may/18/marked-decli...

              • AceyMan a day ago

                "I have great respect for the semicolon; it is a mighty handy little fellow." — Abraham Lincoln

                • DaSHacka a day ago

                  I'm more curious about the usage of em/en dash, most people in my life had no idea it existed.

                  I myself only discovered them for the first time when reading a punctuation site to ensure I was using semicolons grammatically correctly.

                  • dx4100 a day ago

                    I've been using double hyphens (which auto-corrects to emdash now) for as long as I can remember. Now that it's a marker of AI, I find myself removing it whenever I reply to comments.

                    • undefined a day ago
                      [deleted]
                      • nunez a day ago

                        I always used three hyphens in place of the emdash; easier to type.

                        • saurik 8 hours ago

                          While I've seen it in tooling like markdown--with two being an endash--that's very very wide... I am very sure the convention has always been to use two hyphens for an mdash (which is even easier to type! ;P).

                          • DaSHacka a day ago

                            Some of my acquaintances were doing the same, but unintentionally.

                            I had also thought news articles and the like were using regular hyphens that were extended due to some weird font.

                        • adverbly a day ago

                          Personally I have been using em dash(or some other kind of dash) for everything these days.

                          I know it's probably wrong, but I got the feeling that people won't roast me over a fire if I use it incorrectly.

                          • ydlr a day ago

                            Ms Dickinson, is that you?

                            • dx4100 a day ago

                              Well, now that AI makes heavy use of it, I've been using it less. AI LOVES it.

                            • dusted a day ago

                              I think they forgot to include *.js *.ts *.c *.cpp *.java

                              • sandra_vu a day ago

                                with where we are heading, we might see the 90% drop in the use of –

                                • Geste a day ago

                                  So I guess we are doing our part here ? Trying to sneak one semicolon for the count ? I'm not sure even when to even use them correctly. They always fall flat or make sound pretentious; both of which I try to avoid.

                                  • nunez a day ago

                                    The semicolon was always a confusing symbol; it makes even less sense in typical text-style conversations on phones. you can use a period in its place most of the time.

                                    • dowager_dan99 a day ago

                                      I will miss the semicolon, but I'm more concerned about punctuation in general. If I punctuate a text message my teenage daughter will respond "are you mad at me"

                                      • ryao a day ago

                                        Whenever someone misuses the word mad, I think of this:

                                        https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Ao4WTcMtY8

                                        • nunez a day ago

                                          It's hard af to type on screen keyboards, especially with increasingly-wrong autocorrect keyboards.

                                          • BeFlatXIII a day ago

                                            I deliberately use punctuation to flex and intimidate others. Only those undaunted by the weird glyphs are worthy of my respect.

                                          • undefined a day ago
                                            [deleted]
                                            • eimrine a day ago

                                              I would like to say this about colons. Semicolons means the sentence is too hard, sometimes it will look easier with parentheses.

                                              • HKH2 a day ago

                                                Comma splices are not an improvement.

                                              • pfdietz a day ago

                                                Commas, on the, other hand, are turning up, everywhere.

                                                https://theonion.com/commas-turning-up-everywhere-1819569774...

                                                • derbOac a day ago

                                                  Periods too. Periods and commas are being used incorrectly in place of semicolons, ellipses, and em dashes.

                                                  • treetalker a day ago

                                                    Netizens frequently misuse question marks in place of periods to indicate surprise?

                                                    And what even do they use even after interrogatories for? What even is that?

                                                    • dowager_dan99 a day ago

                                                      still beats people? who talk? like this?

                                                    • dx4100 a day ago

                                                      I've seen people use them as a way to replace pauses in speech. I see it more with boomers / Gen-X.

                                                      example:

                                                      he isn't wrong... why do you think that ... it's a good thing

                                                  • qgin a day ago

                                                    The utility : pretentiousness ratio is too low.