• undefined 3 hours ago
    [deleted]
    • adastra22 4 days ago

      I'm confused--what's the security risk in building a container?

      • bilbo-b-baggins an hour ago

        Fundamentally building a container involves running a container - each layer is executed in turn as a temporary container.

        The same risks that running an unknown container has - are had by building one.

        For reference there have been quite a few CVEs related to container escape: https://www.paloaltonetworks.com/blog/cloud-security/leaky-v...

        • Telstrom90 4 days ago

          You're running untrusted code. Every RUN command in a user's Dockerfile is executed during build, which means you're executing arbitrary commands from strangers on your own infrastructure. If you're not isolating that properly, it's a security risk.

          • adastra22 3 days ago

            Inside the container though. The whole point of which is that it sandboxes and isolates the running code.

            • dijit 34 minutes ago

              Containers in linux are primarily a shipping method (as Docker themselves try to inform you with the visual of a shipping container).

              Just like real shipping containers, dangerous things inside can leak out - the isolation is not foolproof by any means, in fact if someone has the express wish of violating the isolation boundary it's barely an inconvenience.

              • amluto 6 hours ago

                Maybe the default form of RUN is kinda sorta safe [0].

                How about ADD? Or COPY? Or RUN —-mount=type=bind,rw…?

                Over the last ten years or so we’ve progressed from subtle-ish security holes due to memory unsafety and such to shiny tools in shiny safe languages that have absolutely gaping security and isolation holes by design. Go us.

                [0] There is some serious wishful thinking involved there.

                • RainyDayTmrw 5 hours ago

                  This blog post[1] explains why that is not a safe assumption.

                  [1]: https://www.aquasec.com/blog/container-isolation/